Mergers and Acquisitions (M&A) aim for financial stability of a business and wealth maximization of shareholders. It provides a potentially bigger and diversified market share. In these days, it is the most commonly use methods for the growth of companies. M&A are a dominant means of globalization and is key to scaling up and internationalization.
The potential problems of M&As are aplenty. Ego issues, inflated books, race against time, misrepresentations, etc. As long as the business looks profitable, the merged / acquisition parties are happy but when profits go south, then the finger pointing begins.
M&As should be familial not financial. If M&As are driven purely by finance, it is going to be a disaster for the business. Finance in business rarely takes a long-term view. It is the maximization of profits in the shortest time. Finance people laugh all the way to the bank. Maybe it is solely driven by time value of money. But great businesses are the greatest collateral damage if such a view is adopted.
Collaborations and synergies, often touted as reasons for M&As, are highly advantageous to M&A parties. This brings in, among other things, cost savings + efficiencies (CSE), value, returns and profitability. CSE brings in sharing of resources, centralization of corporate functions and systems, elimination of duplicate overheads, optimization of over-capability, shared networks, business optimization, managing financial risk, elimination of double incidence of taxation, shared technology and human resource reallocation. These can bring about high profitability by itself.
Though the term “merger” implies a creation of a single entity from two or more equals this does not work in practice. There is no i-contact – both in terms of seeing eye to eye and discarding egos; both of speaking on the same eye level and equal egos. In most merger discussions, getting the two to see eye to eye itself is a daunting task. There will always be a bigger equal in terms of higher revenues or profits, or in terms of potential growth or their war-chest. And when the captains of the business come to an understanding, the professionals will come in with their own set of needs and wants to potentially scuttle the deal. This is worse in an acquisition. There will always be a difference of opinion in every aspect of valuation depending upon the buy or the sell side. Warren Buffet’s “price is what you pay, value is what you get” would probably be the anti-thesis of such business deals.
Non-prima inter pares
The big problem and headaches for M&A reasons are many a times the perception of primus inter pares. There is always the issue of one being bigger than the other. Whether it be in terms of revenues or profits or growth or talent or arrogance of cash. Substantial amount of time is spent in sorting out the babel from benefits. Hence when 2 or more parties get into a room, it is very difficult for them to have a balanced discussion or negotiation and this leads to high protraction of deal completion.
Human capital (HC) deals with all three tenses – past, present and future. It is strategic and takes into consideration issues beyond logic as well. HC is probably the first collateral damage in an M&A. While M&As are supposed to bring in CSE of scale, paradoxically, most of the valuable existing experience in a company is lost in redundancies, lay-offs, retrenchment, human resource conflicts. This capital which has high return on investment, must be captured and reallocated in an M&A.
Professionals assisting in M&As are also part of HC. If the professionals’ vision is not aligned with M&A parties, the M&A is headed towards dangerous times. Such professionals, even with good intentions, will take the M&A one step forward, but 3 steps back.
On a different note, an interesting development in HC companies getting into an M&A would be the development of big data and analytics and its application on the experience of individuals. With most interested individuals expressing / uploading their thoughts in some form of the other on the web, one day sufficient processing speed and bandwidth can give us the benefit of this experience.
Time is money, time is the enemy. But it is a long-term investment. In the haste to close a deal, most M&As gloss over critical issues. Time is also the culprit in closing deals over weekends resulting in missing out potential added costs, disputes, rushing go-to-market, pushing to agreements without careful consideration and relationship building (cf. guanxi below). Time is not speed and speed is not time. What is important, is speed based on calculated timing. An M&A built on relationships takes time, but it calculates the long-term benefits of working well together resulting in a high average speed.
The importance is always understated and misunderstood, especially in international M&As.
Merged & Acquired – Solution
- M&As are delicate subjects. In these cases, I say that the shortest distance between two points is never a straight line. Diplomatic skills, EQ, empathy, motivational theory applications, change management and cultural integrations are pre-requisites for a successful M&A. This actually saves time in the long run and are the multiple points that in fact bring the main 2 points together.
- Capture and reallocation of HC in merged or acquired companies. This capital which has high return on investment in an M&A.
- Guanxi – Like most Chinese expressions, guanxi is complex. Simply put, it means “relationships” (but without hierarchy). Build understanding and acceptance before M&A. It forms what I call Human Due Diligence.
- Find professionals that give you the paradoxical and elusive “Collaborative M&A with Organic Growth” that consider contribution by all parties to an M&A to help each other increase output, increase customer base, improve and develop new products and successfully deploy HC.
For partnerships, speaker and general business enquiries with 2iB Partners:
|Contact Person||Dylan Tan|
YOU MAY LIKE
The Future Employee
The future is now. Well, in some cases, the future is past. The sci-fi movie Blade Runner, made in 1982 and 2017, set the future in 2019. It got some things right (or at least headed that way in terms of flying cars and “android” helpers) and some things wrong (like...
Philippines 4.0 Skills Conference | 20-21st Nov
In conjunction with Philippine Trade Training Center, Global MSME Academy, Thames International and accelebator, 2iB Partners will be speaking on Emerging Trends in Retail, HR Transformation and how to internationalize your business. Learn from 12 different...
Mergers & Acquisitions – simplified. Or, a practical guide
3. Preliminary Due Diligence
4. Expressions of Interest
5. Detailed Due Diligence
6. Definitive Documentation
7. Post M&A
M&A begins with an idea in a company that helps it increase market share and access, t
Is having a Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) program just a cost to your company?
Developing great companies that give back is more about devising a clear Corporate Social Responsibility (“CSR”) program aligned with the company’s goals and values rather than forcefully integrating CSR with their business strategies and goals. Instead of passing it off as a short term marketing gimmick, CSR should be seen as a long term investment strategy.
3 Key Notes Before Entering a New Market [Video & Transcript]
The above is a video taken during one of 2iB Partners master class where our advisor Mr. Richard Eu answers a question on “3 Key Notes Before Entering a New Market” by a business owner, Mr. Peh Zheng Yang. [Begin Transcript] Mr. Peh: You mentioned something like for...
Why is Instagram a Vital Part of your Marketing Strategy
Throw a stone and you will probably find someone who is taking a photo to post on Instagram. There has also been a strong push for consumer centric businesses to produce and develop products that are “Insta-worthy”. Whether it’s